Sunday, April 6, 2008

Death and Closure

Paralleling the emphasis on a proper burial, Fleishman’s article on Erwin Kowalke illuminates the universality and timelessness of closure. For example, Kowalke describes his experience: “We identified one soldier awhile back. His 92-year-old widow from Berlin came to the cemetery in Halbe…When I saw that old woman in a wheelchair holding the box of bones that were her husband and saying, 'Oh, Werner, I know where you are. Now, I can have peace,' I knew that what I do matters.” Going back to lecture, Hart explained that the Roman Catholics got closure from seeing the physical body of the deceased at the funeral. The physical embodiment of a person still holds its “substance” and importance even if only the remains are left. Because when deceased, the physical represents the concrete connection the mourning have with the dead, it’s important to show respect through whatever burial practices in order to gain closure. Transcending the human need to feel close to the departed, Antigone’s audacious act in offering her brother a proper burial is rooted in her desire to conform to the Greek gods and Greek morals. Although the 92-year-old widow’s priorities probably wasn’t to the Greek gods, being reunited with her husband was her way of rectifying with her beloved’s death. Both Antigone and the widow were presented a loss and, in a sense, relieved when closure was attained.

6 comments:

Erin Trapp said...

"substance" is such a great word choice--already it relates to the joseph article's discussion of "ethical substances" and partial truths--it's interesting to think about how the closure of proper burial relates to the resolution required by hegel's dialectic (the synthesis moment).

Scott Yoshimoto said...

I completely agree, great job associating substance and closure with the material discussed in lecture. Having a proper burial and knowing that the deceased have attained closure also brings closure to the deceased person's loved ones.

mmostama said...

You connected the information from lecture in a very well-manner with your blog entry. I think your comparison of Antigone and the 92 year-old women is very significant and unique. You have presented good evidence that built up to a strong claim.

noelle said...

This post makes a lot of sense and I agree with the whole idea of closure. As a Roman Catholic, I know about the ceremonies performed for the dead. Praying for them and giving them a funeral gives us the opportunities to say our final goodbyes and allows us to make sure that our loved ones will rest in peace.

Akash B said...

I agree. I understand the point you are making and im glad you made the connection to the roman catholic funderal practices because they are still practiced today. It makes it easier when you relate it to something going on or still going on in today's world.

peterr said...

You've drawn a very good and interesting connection of closure from death between Antigone and the article. The conclusion and the sense of relief from the closure is apparent in both piece of work and is almost parallel.